Benjamin Schneer

Associate Professor of Public Policy, Harvard Kennedy School

← ResearchResearch area

Redistricting and gerrymandering

How much do district lines decide who wins, and can maps be drawn more fairly?

Show these 8 papers on the research page

Why it matters

Every ten years, and lately more often, states redraw their districts. Whoever draws the lines can shape which party controls a legislature for a decade. In a democracy a party in power should have some chance of losing it, and lawmakers who cannot lose face less pressure to respond to voters.

What the papers find together

Without constraints, at least one party in every state could draw a legislative majority built to survive almost any likely vote swing. On average, the best possible gerrymander adds more than 20 percentage points to a party’s chance of holding a majority compared with a neutral map, and 50 to 75 points in some states. Most maps passed into law fall well short of those limits, held back by geography, voters and state rules such as compactness requirements and independent commissions. Texas’s maps come closest.

Reformers have workable options. A cut-and-choose rule (Define–Combine) turns the parties’ own incentives into a check on mapmaking bias, with no neutral referee and no deal between the parties. Arizona’s citizen commission shows how an independent body can draw compact, competitive maps. Separate reports for Arizona and Virginia use precinct returns to measure racially polarized voting, and the Arizona reports check whether new maps preserved minority voters’ ability to elect their candidates.

Where to start

  1. Durable Majority Gerrymanders
    Can gerrymandering put a legislative majority beyond voters’ reach for a decade?
  2. The Define–Combine Procedure
    Can two rival parties curb gerrymandering without a neutral referee?
  3. Arizona’s Commission
    What can other states learn from Arizona’s independent redistricting commission?