← ResearchRedistricting and gerrymandering Report · 2012
An Analysis of the Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission Congressional District Map
Submitted to the U.S. Department of Justice
Did Arizona’s new congressional map preserve minority voters’ ability to elect their candidates?
Summary
We have been retained by the Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission to analyze data from the congressional district maps drawn for the 2011–2012 redistricting cycle and approved by the Commission. In this report, we estimate the extent of racially polarized voting, determine the identification and electability of the minority groups’ candidates of choice, and (through a new method we introduce for the first time here) offer one way to evaluate whether stronger districts could have been drawn. Overall, we find that the two voting rights districts have similar levels of racially polarized voting between the baseline and new plans. On the basis of the quantitative information we have used, it seems straightforward to identify the candidate of choice of the Hispanic community and both new districts would seem to have the ability to elect these candidates. We also find that it would be difficult, and unnecessary if it were possible, to draw districts more favorable to minorities. We see no evidence of retrogression.
The short answer
Both voting rights districts appear able to elect Hispanic voters’ preferred candidates, with no sign that the new map left minority voters worse off. Drawing more favorable districts would have been difficult and unnecessary. The report went to the Justice Department, which approved the plan the first time it was submitted, something no earlier Arizona redistricting plan had achieved.