Benjamin Schneer

Associate Professor of Public Policy, Harvard Kennedy School

← ResearchRedistricting and gerrymandering Article · 2024

A Partisan Solution to Partisan Gerrymandering: The Define–Combine Procedure

Political Analysis 32 (3): 295–310

Can two rival parties curb gerrymandering without a neutral referee?

Abstract

Redistricting reformers have proposed many solutions to the problem of partisan gerrymandering, but they all require either bipartisan consensus or the agreement of both parties on the legitimacy of a neutral third party to resolve disputes. In this paper, we propose a new method for drawing district maps, the Define–Combine Procedure, that substantially reduces partisan gerrymandering without requiring a neutral third party or bipartisan agreement. One party defines a map of 2N equal-population contiguous districts. Then the second party combines pairs of contiguous districts to create the final map of N districts. Using real-world geographic and electoral data, we employ simulations and map-drawing algorithms to show that this procedure dramatically reduces the advantage conferred to the party controlling the redistricting process and leads to less-biased maps without requiring cooperation or non-partisan actors.

The short answer

The procedure puts the parties’ own incentives to work. One party draws twice as many districts as needed and the other pairs them up. The advantage of controlling redistricting drops sharply and maps turn out less biased, with no neutral referee and no agreement between the parties.

In the press

Related papers