Stephen Ansolabehere, Maxwell Palmer, and Benjamin Schneer
In Governing in a Polarized Age: Elections, Parties, and Political Representation in America, eds. Alan S. Gerber and Eric Schickler (Cambridge University Press)
How has Congress’s output changed since 1789, and does divided government slow it down?
About
A chapter reporting on an undergraduate lecture course modeled on David Mayhew’s Divided We Govern. Students each took a period of U.S. history and identified major acts using common sources and a shared definition, compiling 1,040 significant laws enacted from 1789 onward. Analyzing that record across eras, we find that major lawmaking peaked in the 1960s and that unified party control is associated with three to four more significant laws per Congress, with no consistent effect on total laws passed.
The short answer
In a new record of 1,040 significant laws enacted since 1789, major output remained low through the 19th century, peaked in the 1960s and has declined since. Accounting for historical eras, unified party control is associated with three to four more significant laws per Congress (about a third more than under divided control), with no consistent effect on total laws passed.
Related papers
Divided Governmentone grew out of the other Does divided government stop Congress from passing major laws?
Extreme Leaderssame question: what determines what Congress gets done? Why do parties choose leaders more extreme than their typical member?