Benjamin Schneer

Associate Professor of Public Policy, Harvard Kennedy School

← ResearchLegislative politics Article · 2018

Divided Government and Significant Legislation: A History of Congress from 1789 to 2010

Social Science History 42 (1): 81–108

Does divided government stop Congress from passing major laws?

Abstract

This article presents and analyzes the most comprehensive database to date of significant acts of Congress, from 1789 to 2010, to test whether divided party control of government affects the number of important acts Congress passes. We find that unified control corresponds with one additional significant act passed per Congress in the nineteenth century and four additional such acts in the twentieth century. However, party control of government cannot explain the broad historical trends in the rate at which Congress passes significant legislation. Nixon in 1969 was far more successful with a Democratic Congress than was McKinley in 1897 with a Republican one.

The short answer

Unified party control corresponds to about one extra major law per Congress in the 19th century and four in the 20th, and it cannot explain the broad historical swings in how much major legislation Congress passes.

In one number

+4 significant laws per Congress under unified party control in the 20th century (+1 in the 19th)

In the press

Related papers