← ResearchPetitions and citizen voice Article · 2022
The Popular Origins of Legislative Jurisdictions: Petitions and Standing Committee Formation in Colonial Virginia and the Early US House
Journal of Politics 84 (3): 1727–1745
Why did early American legislatures create standing committees organized by topic?
Abstract
Committee formation in early American legislatures happened when those assemblies were inundated with petitions, a relationship unexamined in institutional political science. We develop a model where a floor creates committees to respond to topic-specific petitions, predicting committee creation when petitions (1) are topically specific, (2) are spread across constituencies, and (3) have complex subject matter, and predicting committee appointments from petition-heavy constituencies. Analysis of case studies and with two original data sets (petitions sent to the Virginia House of Burgesses from 1766 to 1769, and over 100,000 petitions sent to Congress and recorded in the House Journal, 1789–1875) shows that petitions, their complexity, and their geographic dispersion predict committee creation. Our theoretical argument helps reinterpret the entropy of political agendas and the origins of standing committees in American legislatures.
The short answer
Committees formed to help lawmakers respond to new groups organizing around specific issues. Topics drawing complex, widespread petitions were more likely to get standing committees, which helps explain why committees cover policy topics rather than regions. The model also predicts that lawmakers from petition-heavy areas were appointed to those committees.
In one number
100,000+ petitions sent to the U.S. House (1789–1875) tracked in the dataset