← ResearchPetitions and citizen voice Working paper
From Petitioners to Voters: Assessing the Effect of Electoral Reform on Citizen Engagement and Agenda Setting
When voters could elect their senators directly, did they petition them less?
Abstract
For constituents, the right to petition provides a point of access to a legislative body. For lawmakers, petitions provide a rich source of information on constituents’ preferences. When democratizing reforms strengthen electoral accountability, they may weaken other ties between constituents and lawmakers by diminishing alternative forms of engagement, such as petitioning. This paper studies the interplay between direct election and direct contact with lawmakers by examining changes in petitioning that occurred when the 17th Amendment imposed direct election to the Senate, giving many Americans the ability to vote directly for or against their Senator for the first time. Rates of petitioning to the Senate declined by roughly 10% due to the change in electoral institutions. However, political representation as measured by agenda congruence (the degree of alignment in attention paid to agenda items for constituents and lawmakers) improved significantly, with the greatest increases occurring in places without historical traditions of petitioning. These findings underscore the importance of evaluating both constituent and legislator behavior when studying democratizing reforms.
The short answer
Petitions to the Senate fell by roughly 10%, but senators’ agendas came to match their constituents’ more closely, especially where petitioning had been rare.
In one number
≈ 10% drop in Senate petitions after voters began electing senators directly