Benjamin Schneer

Associate Professor of Public Policy, Harvard Kennedy School

← ResearchPetitions and citizen voice Article · 2026

Policy Consequences of Civil Society: Evidence from German-American Counter-Mobilization to Prohibition

Journal of Historical Political Economy (Ahead of print)

When can civic groups sway a vote in Congress?

Abstract

What shapes whether civil-society organizations influence policy? We study this question through German-American counter-mobilization to national Prohibition, before and after the state-sponsored suppression that followed US entry into the First World War (WWI). Combining new district-level measures of German-American civil society with a measure of pre-WWI prohibition preferences, we compare two near-identical House votes: the defeated 1914 Hobson Amendment and the successful 1917 Eighteenth Amendment. Holding district preferences fixed, German-American civil society explains member votes on Prohibition in 1914, most strongly in districts where constituents were evenly divided, not in districts that overwhelmingly favored or opposed Prohibition. By 1917, after suppression had hollowed out German-American organizations, that relationship had weakened and districts with the strongest pre-WWI civil society shifted the most toward Prohibition. We estimate that the observed decline in German-American civil society accounts for somewhere between 16 and 37% of the votes Prohibition gained between 1914 and 1917. Our findings add to the understanding of when groups and organizations successfully influence public policy.

The short answer

Even after accounting for local sentiment on Prohibition, German-American civic groups explained 1914 House votes against Prohibition in evenly split districts, though not in districts overwhelmingly for or against it. After wartime suppression hollowed out those groups, their decline accounted for an estimated 16–37% of the votes Prohibition gained by 1917.

In one number

16–37% of the House votes Prohibition gained from 1914 to 1917, explained by the decline in German-American civic groups

Related papers