Benjamin Schneer

Associate Professor of Public Policy, Harvard Kennedy School

Define–Combine

Two rival parties draw a district map with no referee: one party defines twice as many districts as needed, and the other combines them in pairs. Here, you define and the computer combines, always picking the pairing that favors its own side. Can you split the state so the final map beats both parties’ gerrymanders?

If one party drew the map alone

Click or drag across precincts. Click a precinct again to remove it. Keys 1–6 pick a sub-district.

How it works

  1. The state. Each map shows a small state of 30 precincts with equal numbers of voters. The number on a precinct shows the leading party’s vote share; blue leans Democratic and red leans Republican.
  2. Define. You cut the state into 6 contiguous sub-districts of 5 precincts each. Contiguous means one connected piece: you can walk from any precinct in a sub-district to any other without leaving it. Every precinct must end up in a sub-district.
  3. Combine. The other party pairs neighboring sub-districts into 3 districts. It looks at every possible pairing and takes the one that wins it the most districts. A district goes to the party with more votes in it.
  4. Score. Your final map is compared against the map each party would draw on its own. You win when both parties fare better than under the other party’s gerrymander. Solving a map unlocks the next one.

The research

The procedure comes from A Partisan Solution to Partisan Gerrymandering: The Define–Combine Procedure (Maxwell Palmer, Benjamin Schneer, and Kevin DeLuca, Political Analysis, 2024). Tested on real state maps and election results with map-drawing programs playing each side, it substantially reduces the advantage of controlling redistricting. It produces less biased maps without a neutral referee or a bipartisan deal.

These maps show the same thing in miniature. On each, the best outcome the definer can reach against a combiner playing its best lies between the two gerrymanders, and only a careful cut gets there. For the full two-player version with 50 precincts, see Maxwell Palmer’s Define–Combine Game; a summary and simulator at definecombine.com.