← ResearchElections and voters Article · 2026
A Drag on the Ticket? Estimating Top-of-the-Ticket Effects on Down-Ballot Races
American Journal of Political Science 70 (4): 1621–1637
Does a weak or extreme candidate for governor or Senate drag down the rest of the party’s ticket?
Abstract
Campaign staff, journalists, and political scientists commonly attribute the poor performances of a party’s down-ballot candidates to low-quality or extreme top-of-the-ticket candidates, but empirical evidence on this conventional wisdom is scant. We estimate the effect of candidate quality and ideology in gubernatorial and U.S. Senate elections on co-partisan vote shares in down-ballot U.S. House races. While naive estimates imply that top-of-the-ticket candidates influence down-ballot outcomes, after accounting for correlations in candidate quality/ideology across offices, we estimate near-zero statewide top-of-the-ticket effects on U.S. House elections. We similarly observe near-zero top-of-the-ticket effects in the further-down-ballot settings of state-legislative and county-legislative elections. Overall, voters exhibit a strong capacity to discern differences in quality and ideology across offices and incorporate this information into their vote choice throughout the time period under investigation. However, in line with other research, this link between candidate quality/ideology and election outcomes has weakened considerably in recent years.
The short answer
A party’s candidates for different offices tend to share similar strength and ideology in the same places and years. Accounting for that overlap, governor and Senate candidates have near-zero effects on House, state-legislative and county-legislative races.
In one number
≈ 0 effect of governor and Senate candidates’ quality or ideology on their party’s House vote
In the press
- Oct 25, 2026 · quoted Down to the wire in 5th Congressional District (opens in a new tab) The Gazette (Colorado Springs)
- Oct 2, 2026 · feature Does the top of the ticket influence down-ballot races? (opens in a new tab) Harvard Kennedy School